We’ll Pick Up Next Week · Vol. 8
Give your villain a Tuesday
One small human habit that turns a boss fight into a villain your table will remember, plus villains who don’t sit around waiting for the party.
Hey y’all,
Welcome to Volume 8, and welcome back to the workshop.
Let’s get this out of the way up front: yes, i know it isn’t Tuesday, and yes I know I’m late. Sometimes the villain in the story is just life life-ing it’s way into slowing things down. Like I suspect is true for most of us, the day job and regular todos snagged up way more of my time this week and I turned around and saw it was Wednesday. So…sorry for the delay, but I promise it’s worth it.
Halloween is a little over a week away, which means every streaming service on earth is already putting a villain or monster in front of you. Coincidentally, that’s exactly what we’re talking about today.
Think about the villain your table still talks about. I don’t mean the one that was the toughest fight, or the one that had the single cool piece of art. I mean the one your players still quote at each other months later. I’d bet it isn’t the one with the most hit points or legendary resistances. It’s the one who did something small and human at exactly the wrong moment and made the whole table stop for a minute and think.
Most of the villains we run never get there, and it isn’t for lack of effort. We spend hours on the lair, the minions, the master plan, and the stat block, and then the big reveal lands with a shrug because the players never had a reason to think of the villain as a person. They’ve never considered them as anything more than the stat block or the minion master that we built. We’ve all been there, and it’s a rough feeling after that much prep, for you and for the players who wanted the fight to matter and have real meaning.
Here’s the good news: it doesn’t take more prep. It takes one detail. A dragon with a great stat block is a fight your players will have forgotten by next month. A dragon who keeps a room full of the shoes of everyone she has eaten, sorted by size, is someone they’ll still be talking about years from now. It’s the same dragon with the same stats, and the only thing you changed was one small, strange, human detail.
So give your villain a Tuesday. What I mean by that is, give them one ordinary thing they do when nobody’s watching, something that has nothing to do with the master plan.
The letter · Free, on Substack Subscribe
THE PROMPT: what your villain does when nobody’s watching
Roll a d6 for the villain your party is circling. This is the thing they would never do in front of the heroes, which is exactly the thing that makes them feel real.
They write letters to someone who is never going to write back, and they’ve kept every unsent draft.
They’re kind to one specific servant and cruel to anyone who notices.
They keep a small, ugly trophy from the worst thing they ever did, and they can’t bring themselves to throw it out.
They’re afraid of something completely ordinary, like deep water, small rooms, or birds (thank you, Mr. Hitchcock, for that phobia).
They’ve been rehearsing a speech for the party for weeks, and they’re really hoping they get to give it.
They take care of something, whether that’s a garden, an old dog, or a sick sister who has no idea what they really are.
Here’s what that looks like in practice. Your party has been chasing the Margrave for three sessions. They finally raid his summer house, expecting traps and guards, and instead they find a greenhouse full of roses that somebody has clearly been watering every morning. There’s a pair of muddy gloves on the bench and a handwritten note to the staff about which bushes need shade. Nobody is there, nothing attacks, and your players will still spend twenty minutes in that greenhouse arguing about what it means. The next time the Margrave shows up, he’s the guy who waters his roses every morning, and every player at the table is going to wonder whether they can use that, or whether they even want to.
If your villain has been offscreen the whole campaign, this works even better, because it’s the first real look your players get at them. Drop it into a letter they intercept, a servant who talks too much, a room they break into, or wherever it fits in your adventure. And if your villain is a monster with no human side at all, give the habit to the cult leader or the lieutenant instead, because somebody close to the monster still has a normal Tuesday every once in a while.
I’m not saying every villain needs a tragic backstory or a redemption arc (some villains just need to be stopped, and that’s fine). What I’m saying is give your players one glimpse, one time. You don’t have to explain it, and you don’t have to pay it off right away. Let them see it, then pay attention to how they talk about that villain afterward, because I’d bet it changes for the rest of the campaign.
THE FIND
If the Tuesday is what your villain does when nobody’s watching, this week’s Find is about what they’re doing while the party is busy with everything else. It comes from Tabletop Toolkit, a newsletter full of practical tools for GMs who would rather run a good game than spend all week prepping one. Back in July they wrote “The Best Villains Don’t Wait for the Players,” a guide to running a villain with a real goal, a deadline, and a plan that can survive contact with your players. They walk through four questions to ask about any villain: what they actually want, why they need it now, what they can use to get it, and what happens if nobody stops them. My favorite bit is their reminder that “power” isn’t specific enough to count as a goal, since “everyone wants power, including most house cats.”
They’re still putting out good stuff, too. Their newest post, “The Lazy GM’s Guide to Making Shopping Interesting,” would have fit right into Volume 6 alongside our rope-and-mule problem. Their idea of a locked door behind the shop counter that knocks from the other side every so often is the kind of detail I’d steal in a heartbeat. Go read both, then subscribe while you’re there. It’s free: Tabletop Toolkit.
FROM THE WORKSHOP
Once your villain has a Tuesday and a plan, they need something to do between sessions. The Villain Ledger is four sheets and a table of offscreen moves that keep one enemy busy while the party is off doing their own thing. It takes about ten minutes between games, and your players come back to a villain who has been moving the whole time: Villain Ledger.
The always free stuff: The Night’s Ledger, which is two quick prep sheets for game night; the Player Cheat Cards, which keep the rules accessible in a player’s hand instead of in three different books; and The Sundered Page, our whole one-page game you can run tonight. Grab them at The Night’s Ledger, Player Cheat Cards, and The Sundered Page.
Two more free things went up this week, too. The Encounter Complications sample is six cards from the deck, one from each suit, with the deck’s own instructions, so your table can try it before you buy anything. The Dreaming Court is a complete warlock subclass for your players, and it’s pay what you want: six-card sample and The Dreaming Court.
The entire shelf of free and paid stuff all lives at sleepersartifice.com. Come poke around.
ALSO WORTH YOUR INBOX
Mage Advice. They put out practical ideas for GMs every week, and they’ve been at it a while. Back in June of last year they wrote “Your campaign needs a recurring villain. Here’s three.”, and it still fits this issue perfectly. The problem they tackle is a real one: when a villain escapes, the party feels cheated, and when the villain doesn’t escape, you don’t have a recurring villain anymore. Their answer is to give the villain a reason they keep coming back. My favorite of the three is a villain who returns every time with a new immunity to whatever killed them last, which means your players have to figure out a different way to beat them every single time.
More recently, they wrote about a storytelling rule the creators of South Park swear by. If the beats of your story are connected by “and then,” you’ve written a list of events, and if you can connect them with “but” or “therefore,” you’ve written a story. It works just as well on a dungeon as it does on a cartoon: Mage Advice.
Thanks for hanging with me. If this was useful, forward it to someone at your table. That’s how this thing grows. And if you write a newsletter too and this feels like a fit, hit reply. I’m always looking for good neighbors to recommend. We’ll pick up next week.
-J


