We’ll Pick Up Next Week · Vol. 11
How to rob your players
Four rules for taking something from the party without the table feeling cheated, two decades of OSR table wisdom, and a single line that is an essential first step in character creation.
Hey y’all,
Welcome to Volume 11, and welcome back to the workshop.
Back in the Halloween issue I said that robbing the players was a different kind of session and we’d get to it in a few weeks. It’s been…at least a session’s worth of time since then. Thanksgiving is also right around the corner, which is supposed to be the season for giving, so naturally this is the issue about taking things away.
Here’s how it usually goes wrong. The party has been winning for six sessions straight, nothing has cost them anything, the loot pile keeps growing, and you’re looking at a runaway train that may derail your game. You want the campaign to have some teeth, so one night a thief slips into camp while they sleep, you roll a stealth check behind the screen, and in the morning you announce that the wizard’s spellbook is gone. Cool in concept, but bad in practice. Here’s what happens: the table goes quiet in the bad way. Somebody says “that’s not fair,” and the thing is, they’re right. From their side of the screen it was something that happened to them, with no way to see it coming and nothing they could have done about it.
If you’ve been GMing or playing long enough, you’ve been on both sides of that one, and it stings no matter how you shake it. You wanted stakes, and your players feel like you reached across the table and took a toy.
Here’s the thing, though. Loss is one of the best tools we have. A thing the party loses matters more to them than a thing they find, every single time, and it’s the quickest way I know to turn a pile of treasure back into a story. The difference between a robbery that makes the campaign better and one that makes the table mad comes down to four simple rules.
The letter · Free, on Substack Subscribe
THE TOOL: four rules for robbing your players
Take something they chose. Only steal what they’ve shown you they care about, and never something they need in order to play their character. The fighter’s family shield that she has described three times is fair game. The fighter’s only weapon is off limits, because then she spends the next session unable to do her job, and nobody at the table has fun watching that. If you aren’t sure what they care about, listen for the thing they named. Players name the things they love.
Let them see it happen, or see where it went. No stealth rolls behind the screen while they sleep. Either the theft happens where they can see it (the pickpocket brushes past in the market, the riders take the wagon while the party is pinned down at the bridge) or they wake up to evidence they can follow: a cut strap, a muddy boot print, a neighbor who saw somebody in a green hood heading east. The first thing they learn about the robbery should also be the first clue to getting it back.
Make the robbery the start of something. A thing that’s gone for good is just a loss. A thing that’s out there somewhere is a quest, and your players will chase it harder than any job a stranger in a tavern ever handed them. Know where it went before you take it, and know who has it now, because they’re going to ask within about thirty seconds.
Give it back changed. When they catch up to it, it shouldn’t be the same thing they lost. The shield has a new dent and someone else’s blood on it. The spellbook has three new pages in handwriting the wizard doesn’t recognize. Now the thing they loved has a story attached to it, and they’ll tell that story for the rest of the campaign.
Here’s what that looks like in practice. If you’ve been here since Volume 6, you remember Turnip the mule. The party has hauled Turnip across four sessions and named him, fed him, and argued about him, so he’s fair game. They camp outside a village, and in the morning the picket rope is cut clean, Turnip is gone, and at the edge of camp there’s a set of small boot prints in the mud and a child’s wooden sword that somebody dropped on the way out. Nobody rolled anything. The ranger follows the prints a mile down the road to a farm where a kid of about ten has Turnip in the barn, because the family’s own mule died last month and the harvest is rotting in the field. Maybe the mule got eaten, or something is causing the rot? Now your players have a problem that has nothing to do with hit points. They can take their mule back from a crying kid, they can hire Turnip out for the week and come back for him, they can hunt down the problem, or they can do something I haven’t thought of, which is usually what happens. And when Turnip does come home, he’s got a ribbon braided into his mane and he won’t cross a stream anymore unless somebody walks next to him. He’s the same mule, but he also isn’t.
One edge case. If a player goes quiet in the way that means they’re upset and not the way that means they’re thinking (you’ll know the difference), give the thing back fast and make the thief pay for it. Nothing about this is worth a bad night for someone at your table.
I’m not saying rob them every week (do that and they’ll start sleeping in shifts, and your campaign turns into a security detail). What I’m saying is once in a while, take one thing they love, let them watch it go, and make sure it’s out there waiting to be found. You get a table that cares about something again, and you get a villain they’ll remember without writing a single stat block.
THE FIND
This week’s Find is OSR Rocks!, where Alexander Jatscha-Zelt writes about two decades of running old-school games and the games his studio, Golem Productions, puts out. Back in April he wrote a post about going with the flow while running adventures, and it’s full of the kind of advice you only get from somebody who has run a lot of tables. He wants your descriptions kept simple but specific, your encounters prepped before game night instead of rolled up at the table, and your random tables used with judgment instead of as a rulebook. My favorite bit is a habit he borrows called Stars and Wishes, where every player names one thing they loved about the session and one thing they want more of next time, which is the fastest honest feedback you’ll ever get as a GM. He also makes the case that laughter at the table doesn’t break the mood, it resets it, and I’ve found that to be true more often than not. He’s still at it, too. His newest post is about what the OSR actually is and why it shapes how he designs games without defining all of it. Go read both, then subscribe while you’re there. It’s free: OSR Rocks!.
ALSO WORTH YOUR INBOX
Komodo Games. Michael Dozark posts every Sunday about running games and designing his own, and he’s been at it about two years. His newest post asks what the first step of making a character actually is, and his answer is that it has nothing to do with picking a class. He walks through how a handful of systems handle it, and lands on a one-line concept that ties the character to the mechanics, which in his own design is a single word that earns the player experience when they play it well. If your table makes a new character this month, start there: Komodo Games.
FROM THE WORKSHOP
Once your players are chasing the thief, the chase itself needs to be more than a string of athletics checks. Pursuit Complications is a deck of 36 chase cards, and every card is a stretch of ground with two ways across. The hard way costs you risk, and the long way costs you ground while the quarry gets smaller. Draw one when the chase starts and another when it starts to drag: Pursuit Complications.
The always free stuff: The Night’s Ledger, which is two quick prep sheets for game night; the Player Cheat Cards, which keep the rules in a player’s hand instead of in three different books; The Sundered Page, our whole one-page game you can run tonight; the Encounter Complications sample, six cards from the deck so your table can try it out; and The Dreaming Court, a warlock subclass that’s pay what you want. Grab them at The Night’s Ledger, Player Cheat Cards, The Sundered Page, six-card sample, and The Dreaming Court.
The entire shelf of free and paid stuff all lives at sleepersartifice.com.
Thanks for hanging with me this week. If this was useful, forward it to someone at your table. That’s how we grow and how we share more ideas. If you publish in our space, hit reply. I’d love to see your work and maybe feature it in an issue. I’m always looking for good neighbors to recommend. We’ll pick up next week.
-J


